Elden Ring · Colossal Weapon | Compare
Choose a variant below. Closely related recipes, conditions or opening branches are collected here so you can compare them without moving between almost identical pages.
The version and limits of the original source apply to every entry. Quantities and requirements belong to the named variant; do not add alternative recipes or opening lines together.
These options share a planning task. Their differences stay visible in the individual rows and calculators.
Requirements are checked for one-handed use only. Scaling grades refer to the source’s base weapon, without upgrade or affinity changes. The load calculator uses your entered maximum load; it does not infer Endurance, damage, buffs or two-handing rules.
Plan your scenario
Using this reference
For Colossal Weapon, check each one-handed requirement before looking at weight and scaling grades. Meeting the requirements answers whether those listed thresholds are reached; it is not a damage estimate. A scaling grade describes the recorded base weapon, without selecting an upgrade path.
The load calculation adds this weapon to the other weight you enter. Use your actual maximum equip load to compare two choices fairly. If you change armor as well as the weapon, update the other-weight field rather than attributing the whole difference to the weapon.
Watchdog's Staff
One-handed requirements: Str 34 · Dex 10 · Weight: 19
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 39
- Equip load (%)
- 65
- Strength: 10 / 34 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 10 — Requirements met
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Watchdog's Staff is 34. At 33, you are one point short; at 34, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Watchdog's Staff is listed at 19, compared with 19.5 for Envoy's Greathorn: a difference of 0.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Envoy's Greathorn
One-handed requirements: Str 28 · Weight: 19.5
Base scaling grades: Str D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 39.5
- Equip load (%)
- 65.8333
- Strength: 10 / 28 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Envoy's Greathorn is 28. At 27, you are one point short; at 28, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Envoy's Greathorn is listed at 19.5, compared with 20 for Duelist Greataxe: a difference of 0.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Great Club
One-handed requirements: Str 35 · Weight: 17
Base scaling grades: Str C
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 37
- Equip load (%)
- 61.6667
- Strength: 10 / 35 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Great Club is 35. At 34, you are one point short; at 35, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Great Club is listed at 17, compared with 18 for Axe Of Godfrey: a difference of 1. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Prelate's Inferno Crozier
One-handed requirements: Str 45 · Dex 8 · Weight: 23.5
Base scaling grades: Str C · Dex E
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 43.5
- Equip load (%)
- 72.5
- Strength: 10 / 45 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 8 — Requirements met
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Prelate's Inferno Crozier is 45. At 44, you are one point short; at 45, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Prelate's Inferno Crozier is listed at 23.5, compared with 21.5 for Fallingstar Beast Jaw: a difference of 2. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Duelist Greataxe
One-handed requirements: Str 30 · Dex 10 · Weight: 20
Base scaling grades: Str E · Dex D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 40
- Equip load (%)
- 66.6667
- Strength: 10 / 30 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 10 — Requirements met
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Duelist Greataxe is 30. At 29, you are one point short; at 30, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Duelist Greataxe is listed at 20, compared with 19.5 for Envoy's Greathorn: a difference of 0.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Axe Of Godfrey
One-handed requirements: Str 42 · Dex 14 · Weight: 18
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 38
- Equip load (%)
- 63.3333
- Strength: 10 / 42 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 14 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Axe Of Godfrey is 42. At 41, you are one point short; at 42, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Axe Of Godfrey is listed at 18, compared with 19 for Ghiza's Wheel: a difference of 1. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Dragon Greatclaw
One-handed requirements: Str 30 · Dex 14 · Weight: 16
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 36
- Equip load (%)
- 60
- Strength: 10 / 30 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 14 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Dragon Greatclaw is 30. At 29, you are one point short; at 30, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Dragon Greatclaw is listed at 16, compared with 17 for Great Club: a difference of 1. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Fallingstar Beast Jaw
One-handed requirements: Str 34 · Dex 12 · Int 20 · Weight: 21.5
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex D · Int E
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 41.5
- Equip load (%)
- 69.1667
- Strength: 10 / 34 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 12 — Requirements still missing
- Intelligence: 10 / 20 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Fallingstar Beast Jaw is 34. At 33, you are one point short; at 34, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Fallingstar Beast Jaw is listed at 21.5, compared with 20 for Duelist Greataxe: a difference of 1.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Staff Of The Avatar
One-handed requirements: Str 34 · Weight: 20
Base scaling grades: Str C
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 40
- Equip load (%)
- 66.6667
- Strength: 10 / 34 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Staff Of The Avatar is 34. At 33, you are one point short; at 34, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Staff Of The Avatar is listed at 20, compared with 19.5 for Envoy's Greathorn: a difference of 0.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Ghiza's Wheel
One-handed requirements: Str 28 · Dex 18 · Weight: 19
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 39
- Equip load (%)
- 65
- Strength: 10 / 28 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 18 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Ghiza's Wheel is 28. At 27, you are one point short; at 28, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Ghiza's Wheel is listed at 19, compared with 19.5 for Envoy's Greathorn: a difference of 0.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Giant-crusher
One-handed requirements: Str 60 · Weight: 26.5
Base scaling grades: Str C
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 46.5
- Equip load (%)
- 77.5
- Strength: 10 / 60 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Giant-crusher is 60. At 59, you are one point short; at 60, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Giant-crusher is listed at 26.5, compared with 23.5 for Prelate's Inferno Crozier: a difference of 3. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Golem's Halberd
One-handed requirements: Str 36 · Dex 14 · Weight: 21.5
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 41.5
- Equip load (%)
- 69.1667
- Strength: 10 / 36 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 14 — Requirements still missing
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Golem's Halberd is 36. At 35, you are one point short; at 36, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Golem's Halberd is listed at 21.5, compared with 20 for Duelist Greataxe: a difference of 1.5. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Troll's Hammer
One-handed requirements: Str 28 · Dex 8 · Fai 10 · Weight: 16
Base scaling grades: Str D · Dex E · Fai D
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 36
- Equip load (%)
- 60
- Strength: 10 / 28 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 8 — Requirements met
- Faith: 10 / 10 — Requirements met
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Troll's Hammer is 28. At 27, you are one point short; at 28, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Troll's Hammer is listed at 16, compared with 17 for Great Club: a difference of 1. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Rotten Staff
One-handed requirements: Str 34 · Dex 8 · Weight: 18
Base scaling grades: Str C · Dex E
Plan your scenario
Result
- Total equipped weight
- 38
- Equip load (%)
- 63.3333
- Strength: 10 / 34 — Requirements still missing
- Dexterity: 10 / 8 — Requirements met
Formula
one-handed requirement: entered stat ≥ required stat; equip load % = 100 × (weapon weight + other weight) / maximum load
A worked example
The listed Strength requirement for Rotten Staff is 34. At 33, you are one point short; at 34, that requirement is met. Check the other requirements separately—meeting this one does not clear the whole list.
One useful comparison
For Weight, Rotten Staff is listed at 18, compared with 19 for Ghiza's Wheel: a difference of 1. This compares that field in the recorded variants only. Read the other fields before deciding whether the trade-off matters to your use.
Game and item names below retain the source’s English identifiers so you can find them in the linked documentation.